Identity
Step2 Delve deeper into identity
You have examined your identity as an overview in Step 1, perhaps it could be encapsulated in a blasé comment such as bill's own “upbringing of middle-class conformity” or the other example bill used – “I had a difficult childhood because I had an alcoholic mother”. Delving deeper, zandtaomed wants you to consider what were the key factors of this identity.
The main basis of your identity was established during your upbringing, at different times in your adult life recalling that identity helps you understand how you are coping with your adult life. At the time of bill's upheaval understanding identity as middle-class conformity was essential in helping him understand what was happening in his work life. When he was writing his dedication to bell hooks, understanding his MAWP identity was essential in making sense of the patriarchy - imperialist, white-supremacist, capitalist patriarchy.
Examine key moments in your adult life in which your personal life interacted with your identity – even confronted it.
Step 3 Categorise your identity
When you consider your adult role in society then the characteristics of your identity are often clear, and can be broken down into the 3 characteristics of race, gender and sexuality, and class. It is important for seekers to recognise that the conditioning you have received in your upbringing are still a part of you as an adult, no matter how far along the path you have gone – or think you have gone.
When zandtao consider his own history with the path:-
he often thought he had gone beyond conditioning, but on closer examination of his personal history it became clear that conditioning had impacted on his life after upheaval yet he was not conscious that it was doing so. For a seeker being conscious of what impacts our lives are important, and the further along the path we go the more we want to be able to say “my conditioning has little impact on my life because of my mindfulness”. For this statement to be true we have to work on being sure that conditioning has been released, and that is a purpose of your Seeker Story.
Categorise yourself in terms of race, gender and class. Now write down other aspects of your identity that you feel are important.
Step 4 Recognise and release your identity
This is the step which is the nub of your work on identity. Unfortunately by nature zandtaomed cannot help many of you with this unless you are MAWPs. However as a seeker you are already likely to be equipped with the knowledge to deal with this as you will in some way be conscious of your identity, and as a seeker you are likely to have recognised your identity, and partially released the clinging to it by a younger you.
In bill's own case he has many times revisited his identity as a MAWP – Male, Arrogant, White and Privileged. As bill has already described myself as conforming middle-class, this is an identity description that sufficiently completes the categorisation of step 3. Looking at his upbringing and personal history with regards to this categorisation is deeply releasing. But you need something to measure that categorisation against. To begin with bill looked at his own understanding of the relationship between MAWPs and society – calling it “embracing the MAWP”, but he gained a great deal when I measured that MAWP against bell hooks that he called “Embracing the MAWP by engaging with bell hooks”. This identity process of my Seeker Story is very personal if the engagement is allowed to push the boundaries, so do be careful. Few people like to see the level that their identities are a product of conditioning even seekers, SEEing conditioning is essential to following the path.
The details of the z-quest where zandtao engaged with bell hooks are described in this blog, but where he personally went inside is not for public consumption – it is not just about you when it is identity and involves family. Please respect the privacy of others whether you consider they are following their paths or not. Choosing an elder who respects this privacy is important.
Choosing your identity z-quest:- Whilst this Seeker Story is part of a spiritual path, the book (media?) you choose to engage with in releasing your identity is not specifically spiritual. Identity is concerned with the wellness of the vehicle (vihara), and the lack of wellness arises from conditioning within society – the defiled world. Zandtao chose the book "The will to change, men, masculinity and love" because it was a book that addressed the patriarchal conditioning of this defiled world – the defiled world of imperialist, white-supremacist, capitalist patriarchy. This book of course would not be suitable for different identities. Bell herself went through her own identity awareness when younger, an awareness that led to her feminism, perhaps people whose identity is black and female would choose to follow the awareness that came from the type of groups bell engaged in.
Beyond pointers zandtaomed cannot detail suitable choices for different identities (different to his own) because that choice needs to be experiential. Zandtaomed would welcome suggestions as to different choices that seekers have worked with on their z-quests and found useful.
To give the seeker an understanding of how the seeker can investigate their identity zandtaomed includes here details of "Embracing the MAWP with bell hooks" included in Shadow Process 2 of the chapter on integrating in the Pathtivism Manual:-
The practice of Embracing the MAWP with bell hooks
So we start with a safe space – a support group, counselling, meditation – a safe space. From his own journey, there were these inner themes:-
Inner Theme 1 – Family dynamics
a) Understand the patriarchal abuse in the family whether emotional or violent
b) How was the expression of love in your family? Mother love for the children? Father love for the children? Parents loving each other? Children loving parents?
c) Know the mother and father in you.
Inner Theme 2 – Accepting an abusive childhood
Examine the consequences of the abuse in your life as you were growing up - as an adult.
Inner Theme 3 – Relationships
a) Look at past relationships, see if there is a pattern based on what you inherited from an abusive childhood.
b) Look at the father in you (women – mothers), have you brought him into your relationships.
c) Examine the childhood abuse, are you bringing it into your relationships? Are you abusing your partner in the same way he abused your mother?
d) Are you loving? How much mutual respect do you show? Is control an issue?
e) Examine how you relate sexually. Are you a caring lover? How do you manage lust in your relationship? What is your relationship with masturbation/ejaculation? Is your sex life a substitute for patriarchal success? Does this substitute lead to exploitation of your partner?
Inner-theme 4 – Work
Examine your fulfilment in your work life, can it be improved? Is it based in wage-slavery?
Inner-Theme 5 – Masks with other men
a) Examine your mask. What is it you cannot say?
b) How does your mask relate to patriarchy?
Within bell’s Ch10 there were different issues that she raised that of course would be involved with such a feminist masculinity awareness (quotes are taken from Ch10):-
1) Something wrong
Bradshaw “The feeling that I have done something wrong, that I really don’t know what it is, that there’s something terribly wrong with my very being, leads to a sense of utter hopelessness. This hopelessness is the deepest cut of the mystified state. It means there is no possibility for me as I am; there is no way I can matter or be worthy of anyone’s love as long as I remain myself.” Training can then proceed to turn that feeling into understanding.
Feeling something is wrong with patriarchal conditioning is a good place for the feminist masculinity to start, it is a place where conditioning is beginning to be rejected. Feeling something is wrong is also a good place to start on the path.
2) Addiction
Suffering, caused by lack of integration and rage at the world leads to “alcoholism or substance abuse. Workaholism is the most common addiction in men because it is usually rewarded and not taken seriously as detrimental to their emotional well-being.” “At the moment when addictions stop keeping the pain at bay, many men sink into depression.”
3) Blaming feminism
Understanding feminism and patriarchy is essential to removing conditioning, so investigating if or how much feminism is blamed is part of integration. Are you an active feminist? If not, why not?
4) Pain, Rage and Grief
“many men seeking to be whole must first name the intensity of their rage and the pain it masks.” “Anger often hides depression and profound sorrow. Depression often masks the inability to grieve.” “To grow psychologically and spiritually, men need to mourn. The men who are doing the work of self-recovery testify that it is only when they are able to feel the pain that they can begin to heal.” This is very much the shadow process of Nyanga zandtao described in the Manual, it was not about death of a loved one but about the pain and suffering in love.
“Unable to acknowledge feelings, fathers often cover them up with rage, cruelly severing their own attachment to the son and refusing his love and admiration.” “Our myths and religious stories are full of narratives in which the son is depicted as the father’s enemy, ever poised to steal his power.” “Only the man who chooses a healthy model - wherein the father figure, the adult man of integrity, the guide who shelters, protects, and nurtures the son - can gracefully attend the assertion of his own son’s healthy autonomy.”
5) Control
“The patriarchal model that tells men that they must be in control at all times is at odds with cultivating the capacity to be responsible, which requires knowing when to control and when to surrender and let go.” “At the same time, constructive criticism works only when it is linked to a process of affirmation…. It is the highest realization of compassion and empathy with others.”
6) Willing to Change
“If a man is not willing to break patriarchal rules that say that he should never change — especially to satisfy someone else, particularly a female - then he will choose being right over being loved.”
Training Summary
“Critical analysis is useful when it promotes growth, but it is never enough. The work of affirmation is what brings us together. When men learn to affirm themselves and others, giving this soul care, then they are on the path to wholeness.” “No longer separate, no longer apart, they bring a wholeness that can be joined with the wholeness of others. This is interbeing.” “Men of integrity are not ashamed to serve. They are caretakers, guardians, keepers of the flame. They know joy.” “This is the true meaning of reunion, living the knowledge that the damage can be repaired, that we can be whole again. It is the ultimate fulfillment that comes when men dare to challenge and change patriarchy.”
It is the inner journey that brings such wholeness and integrity, it is a journey that is stronger and carries greater conviction than intellectual awareness. As seekers you rely on the inner Guide to decide on your progress. Bell noted that earlier in the feminist struggle supportive men slipped back because of the ongoing presence of patriarchal conditioning. With an inner journey grows conviction and an ability to withstand and resist the conditioning that tries to pull you back. This conviction grows as the inner journey continues. If feminist masculinity is ongoing then there will be a continuous process of enquiry of what patriarchy's conditioning throws at us; as with any form of conditioning it is our Inner Guide that defines our progress and decides where to lead. We trust our own conviction above what the system throws at us.
Ongoing Evaluation of Disidentification
In this process of developing the Seeker Story, the seeker is trying to release conditioning through disidentification. As we follow our path there is less and less identifying with egos that develop from conditioning. The more we recognise the prevailing tathata, the less we identify with conditioned egos and the more the process of disidentification leads to integration.
However the conditioning concerning identity is very powerful, and the seeker in following the path needs to be wise and discerning. Using the equanimity of love-wisdom the seeker continues to release conditioning through disidentification. The seeker lives in the conditioned world yet seeks to move beyond, but this state of equanimity is not separate from the conditioned world. Conditioning will always try to draw the seeker back into the quagmire of conditioned diversions, and if the seeker does not develop equanimity then attachment to identity questions will continue to develop conditioned egos.
For the MAWP zandtaomed addresses many identity questions because those questions are part of conditioning, and that conditioning is part of tathata that love-wisdom helps us see with our equanimity. This balance of equanimity allows us to see the tathata, the kilesa conditioning, the patriarchy in a way that does not draw us into developing new conditioned egos or draw us into attaching to old conditioned egos. Abiding in equanimity is part of the path for a seeker to avoid conditioning that can arise through attachment to ideals when considering patriarchy, causes when considering emotional attachment, and many such conditioned egos. In terms of embodiment the seeker is active in daily life but equanimity ensures that this activity does not develop conditioned egos. Enquiry is essential to develop this equanimity, and ongoing evaluation of disidentification is required.
|